A. Finding Ideas from Everyday Experiences
1. Record “Small Moments That Bother You” (Noticing)
Carry a notebook (or simply use your smartphone) and write down anything that makes you feel surprised, annoyed, or curious. For example:
“Why do students remain silent when asked to speak English in class, even though they communicate fluently on WhatsApp?”
“Why do I understand learning materials better from YouTube than from textbooks?”
2. Turn Complaints into Research Questions
Complaint: “The reading materials are boring.”
Research question: “What types of texts do students find interesting, and why?”
This can be the starting point for identifying a research problem.
3. Observe Your Immediate Environment
Pay attention to your classroom, campus, social media, textbooks, friends' conversations, and learning or teaching experiences. These everyday experiences are valuable because you have direct access to them and understand their contexts.
4. Apply the Three-Step Pattern: Observe → Question → Investigate
Observe a phenomenon, formulate a question using why, how, or what impact, and then check whether previous studies have addressed it.
5. Remember: Personal Experience Is Not Research Data
Personal experience is only a starting point. To develop it into academic writing, you must support it with relevant theories and previous research and then investigate it using empirical data.
B. Finding Ideas from Previous Studies
1. Start with Keywords Related to Your Interests
Search Google Scholar, Scopus, ERIC, DOAJ, or Garuda (for Indonesian journals) using two or three keywords. For example, “intercultural content” + “EFL textbook.” Try different synonyms and alternative English terms to broaden your search.
2. Select 5–10 Relevant Articles and Read Them Strategically
Do not read every article from beginning to end immediately. Follow this reading sequence:
3. Make Use of the “Limitations” and “Suggestions for Future Research” Sections
These sections are among the easiest sources of research ideas for beginners. Authors often explicitly state: “Future research could investigate...” This may provide an opportunity for your own research topic.
4. Create a Simple Literature Synthesis Table
| Author (Year) | Topic | Theory | Method | Participants/Data | Findings | Research Gap/Limitations |
|---|
After reviewing and filling in information from 8–10 articles, you will usually begin to recognize research patterns and identify potential gaps.
5. Identify Common Types of Research Gaps
Contextual gap: A topic has been investigated in the United States or China but has not yet been explored in Indonesia or your local context.
Participant gap: Previous studies have focused on university students, but not on junior high school students.
Methodological gap: Previous studies have employed quantitative methods, but qualitative research is still needed, or vice versa.
Theoretical gap: A phenomenon can be examined using a different theoretical framework.
Temporal gap: Previous findings are outdated and need to be updated.
Contradictory findings: Researchers A and B have reported conflicting findings that require further investigation.
6. Follow the Citations (Citation Chasing)