No, they are not the same conception, although they overlap in practice. In ELT, multimedia usually refers to the technological/media mix used to deliver instruction, while multimodal refers to the semiotic modes through which meaning is made and learned.[academic.oup][e-journal.undikma.ac][ihworld][thebioscan]
Core difference in conception
Multimedia in ELT (teaching-focused, tool-oriented)
- Defined as the integration of multiple media forms—text, audio, images, animation, video, interactive digital tools—to support teaching and learning.[thebioscan][scribd][kuey]
- Emphasis is on what technologies/media are used in the classroom (e.g., videos, slides, audio recordings, apps).[scribd]
- Often framed as a teaching aid or instructional resource to make lessons more engaging and to provide varied input.[thebioscan][scribd]
Multimodal in ELT (learning-focused, meaning-oriented)
- Defined as the use of multiple semiotic modes—linguistic, visual, aural, gestural, spatial—to construct and interpret meaning.[academic.oup][e-journal.undikma.ac][ihworld][files.eric.ed]
- Emphasis is on how meaning is made through combinations of modes, not just which media are present.[academic.oup][ihworld][scitepress]
- Grounded in social semiotics (Kress, van Leeuwen, New London Group): each mode contributes differently to meaning, and learners develop multimodal literacy (reading/creating multimodal texts).[academic.oup][e-journal.undikma.ac][scitepress][teachingenglishwithoxford.oup]
So:
- Multimedia = multiple media channels/tools (often digital) used in teaching.[thebioscan][scribd]
- Multimodal = multiple meaning-making modes (language, image, sound, gesture, layout) involved in communication and learning.[academic.oup][e-journal.undikma.ac][ihworld]
Where they overlap
In practice, multimedia resources are often multimodal texts: a video, for example, combines linguistic (speech, captions), visual (images, layout), aural (music, sound effects), and sometimes gestural (body language) modes. That’s why in classroom talk the terms can feel similar:[proceeding.unnes.ac][ritassida.weebly]
- A teacher using multimedia (e.g., a video lesson) is typically exposing students to a multimodal text.[thebioscan][proceeding.unnes.ac]
- A multimodal approach in ELT may use multimedia, but its theoretical focus is on how those modes work together for meaning-making, not just on the technology itself.[scitepress][proceeding.unnes.ac][proceeding.unnes.ac]
Implications for ELT
- If your focus is instructional design and tools (“What media should I use?”), you’re working with a multimedia conception.[thebioscan][scribd]
- If your focus is semiotic analysis and literacy (“How do students make meaning from language + image + sound + gesture?”), you’re working with a multimodal conception.[academic.oup][e-journal.undikma.ac][scitepress]
- A strong contemporary ELT stance often combines both: using multimedia resources deliberately to develop learners’ multimodal literacy.[teachingenglishwithoxford.oup][proceeding.unnes.ac][proceeding.unnes.ac]
No comments:
Post a Comment