Appraisal and Ideology Realization in Indonesia State Capital Relocation News Texts



Appraisal and Ideology Realization in Indonesia State Capital Relocation News Texts
April 2024
DOI:
10.22034/ijscl.2024.2022445.3381
Faizal Risdianto
Sumarlam Sumarlam
Djatmika Djatmika
Tri Wiratno


ABSTRACT
This study analyzes the language employed by Kompas, Republika, Media Indonesia, and Jawa Pos regarding the relocation of Indonesia’s capital city, focusing on attitude, graduation, and engagement.
Eight online texts were analyzed using discourse analysis.This paper used systemic functional linguistics as a tool to analyze the texts. The findings revealed a predominance of positive attitude data (67.2% positive, 32.8% negative), predominantly heterogloss in engagement (91.8% heterogloss, 8.2% monogloss), and a majority of raising/sharpening graduation data (75.1% raising/sharpening, 24.9% lowering/softening). This disparity between positive and negative appraisal data signifies significant and contentious issues the government, community leaders, and the general public face concerning the capital city’s relocation. The results of news outlets analysis demonstrated how ideological orientations shape the construction of social and political values, influencing public beliefs and perceptions of the capital relocation project in Indonesia. 
Keywords: Appraisal, News text, Systemic functional linguistics, Social values, Political values


ARGUMENTATIVE WRITING CONTEST 2024

 ARGUMENTATIVE WRITING CONTEST 2024




Dear  All University Students in Indonesia,

My name is Faizal Risdianto & Haryo Aji Nugroho,


Lecturers at UIN Salatiga. We will conduct research on the topic "Appraisal and Ideology in Indonesian Students' Argumentative Writing". For this purpose, we need original articles on argumentative writing. We offer an academic writing contest titled "The Problems and Solutions of English Language Learning in Indonesia/City. of .../village  pf......" 

The article should be written between 600-1000 words on A4 paper size (doc, docx, or RTF file) and SHOULD BE ORIGINAL, NOT AI-generated writing.

The priority is given to original writing, which specifically mentions the learning methods and the area where the student lives and studies and offers the best solution for the problems. The prizes we can offer are only for 4 (four) winners; each will receive IDR 300.000, -plus merchandise/gift from us.
This contest runs from March 25 to May 25, 2024.
If you are interested, please write and fill out this form:  https://s.id/writingcontest2024

 Best Regards, 

Faizal Risdianto & Haryo Aji Nugroho

Mari kita Perbaiki Hubungan dengan ALLAH SWT dan Manusia

Setelah memperbaiki hubungan dengan Allah SWT di bulan ramadhan perlu memperbaiki hubungan dengan manusia

Sebaik apapun hubungan dengan Allah SWT tapi rusak hubungan dengan manusia: suka ngrasani, memfitnah, mem-bully, berbuat aniaya dst akan bangkrut di akhirat jika masih ada salah pada manusia yang belum meng-ikhlas-kan kesalahan-kesalahan kita.

In Class at Indiana Univ. Pennsylvania: "Dude" through the lens of Linguistic Anthropology


 In Class at Indiana Univ. Pennsylvania: "Dude" through the lens of Linguistic Anthropology

The video script discusses the word "dude" from a linguistic anthropology perspective, exploring its layered meanings and implications for masculinity and indexicality. Students conducted surveys to observe how the word is used in different contexts, revealing shifts in language trends and social constructions of identity.


The history of massacres of Muslims in India

 



The history of massacres of Muslims in India is a deeply complex and tragic narrative, marked by a series of events over centuries. Here's a broad overview along a yearly timeline:

1192: The Battle of Tarain - This marked the beginning of Muslim rule in North India when Muhammad Ghori defeated Prithviraj Chauhan. Subsequent centuries saw the establishment of various Muslim dynasties like the Delhi Sultanate and the Mughal Empire.

Happy Ied Mubarak

 


LEARNING 16 TENSES VIA SINGING A SONG along with English Subtitles

 https://youtu.be/JjjvxMtSha8


Learning 16 Tenses via Singing a Song Dear Netizens, Pernahkan Kalian semua mendengar lagu lama oleh Gebi yang awalnya " Pernah ada rasa cinta antara kita kini tinggal kenangan....."? saya Googling ada yang menuliskan judulnya "Tinggal Kenangan" tapi ada juga yang ngasih judul "Jauh Kau Pergi" Nah, karena kita semua ingin menguasai pelajaran Bahasa Inggris terutama Tenses silakan sekarang coba deh kalian ganti lirik lagunya dengan 16 tenses dibawah ini ,,Selamat Mencoba!! Let's Sing Together!! I Sing a song I am singing a song I have sung a song I have been singing a song I sang a song I was singing a song I had sung a song I had been singing a song I will sing a song I will be singing a song I will have sung a song I will have been singing a song I would sing a song I would be singing a song I would have sung a song I would have been singing a song Ooh My Tenses . . Lagu ini dinyanyikan oleh seorang mahasiswi saya bernama Mbak Arina dari SMC-IAIN Salatiga-UKM Seni tarik Suara yang disebut STAIN Music Club (SMC) dan berikut ini adalah videonya.

Faizal Risdianto Scopus ID

 


ID:57213518975]


Faizal Risdianto http://orcid.org/0000-0002-0422-9166 [Scopus ID:57213518975]; English lecturer department, UIN Salatiga, Indonesia

Keynote Speakers

 

 Keynote Speakers 

1. Prof. Dr. Rizwanur Rahman (Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi, India), 

2. Prof. Dr. Tommi Lethonen (Vaaza University Finland),

3. Prof. Dr. Zakiyuddin, Universitas Islam Negeri (UIN) Salatiga, 

4. Prof. Dr. Zaimuarifuddin Shukri Nordin (University of Malaysia Sarawak),  

5. Prof. Dr. Ngainun Naim (UIN Tulungagung).




APPRAISAL FRAMEWORK

 In exploring the application of the Systemic Functional Linguistics (SFL) appraisal framework to the ideology realization of journalists and their media in reporting news texts, particularly those concerning political and socio-economic issues, several novel aspects, research gaps, and potential theoretical contributions can be identified:



### Novelty

Realization of Appraisal and Ideology in Ferdy Sambo Case in Editorial Text of "Kasus Sambo Isih Dawa" and "Ganjaran Murwat Tumrap Kejujuran" in Panjebar Semangat Magazine



 

  • Faizal RisdiantoUniversitas Islam Negeri Salatiga, Indonesia
  • Haryo Aji NugrohoUniversitas Islam Negeri Salatiga, Indonesia
  • Sunardi SunardiUniversitas Dian Nuswantoro, Semarang, Indonesia
  • Teisar ArkidaUniversitas Sebelas Maret, Surakarta, Indonesia
Keywords: appraisal framework, editorial text, ideology, systemic functional linguistics
Abstract

This research aims to identify appraisal devices in two editorial texts in the Javanese magazine Panjebar Semangat on the news texts of Ferdy Sambo case entitled Kasus Sambo Isih Dawa and Ganjaran Murwat Tumrap Kejujuran and describe the ideology of the author of the editorial text. Data were analyzed using the Appraisal System in Functional Systemic Linguistics, including Attitude, Graduation, and Engagement. The results of the appraisal analysis on the first text are 69 attitudes data from 68 clauses. A total of 69 attitudes data were found, consisting of 33 positive attitudes and 36 negative attitudes. Monogloss data with 44 data dominate these attitudes compared to heterogloss data with 25 data. In terms of Graduation, journalists used the intensifier type only eight times. For the second text, 55 attitudes data from 48 clauses. The total of 55 data was dominated by positive evaluations of 43 data, while there were only 12 negative evaluations. It can be interpreted that this editorial text has a very positive nuance. The text is dominated by monogloss data, namely 47 data, compared to heterogloss data, which is only 8 data. The outcomes of the analysis conducted on the editorial texts within the Panjebar Semangat Javanese magazine indicate a predominant reliance on judgment as the principal method of Appraisal, succeeded by appreciation and affect. The analysis explicitly emphasizes the assessment of individual character traits, with Richard, Sambo, and Putri identified as the primary subjects of evaluation. This finding underscores the potential of news as a mechanism for the exercise of social control, with the deployment of judgment serving to consolidate specific societal values and beliefs. This editorial text makes journalists themselves the dominant source of evaluators. In terms of Graduation, journalists also tend to increase their Attitude appraisal using intensifiers. The dominance of monogloss in the editorial text is linguistic evidence that the journalist deliberately composed the editorial text using the point of view of himself.

https://www.indonesian-efl-journal.org/index.php/ijefll/article/view/762

BATCH 2018 UNS LD-LP Linguistics Doctoral Program


 

classifying areas of masculinity

 


To expand upon the concepts introduced by Chafetz in 1978 concerning gender studies theory, particularly in classifying areas of masculinity, the following references offer a diverse range of perspectives and further developments in this field:

1. **Chafetz, J.S. (2006).** "The varieties of gender theory in sociology." In _Handbook of the Sociology of Gender_ (Springer). This work provides an overview of the evolution and variety of gender theories within sociology, including discussions on masculinity patterns. Chafetz also addresses the possibility of married women adopting what he terms the "masculine pattern" in competing with male counterparts in the workforce .

2. **Pitt, S.L., & Fox, C.A. (2012).** "Performative masculinity: A new theory on masculinity." In _Masculinity/Femininity: Re-framing a Fragmented Debate_ (Brill). This paper introduces the concept of "performative masculinity," building on Chafetz's theories to explore how masculinity is enacted and constructed in society .

3. **Chafetz, J.S. (2001).** "Theoretical understandings of gender: A third of a century of feminist thought in sociology." In _Handbook of Sociological Theory_ (Springer). Chafetz summarizes three decades of feminist sociological theory, including changing conceptions of gender roles and masculinity .

4. **Harrison, J.B. (1978).** "Men's roles and men's lives." _Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society_. This article questions the terminology around masculinity and femininity, referencing Chafetz's work and exploring the implications of gender role definitions .

5. **Chafetz, J.S. (1980).** "Theory development, nominal categories, and sex roles." _Free Inquiry in Creative Sociology_. Chafetz discusses the development of gender role theory, specifically addressing the constructs of masculinity and femininity .

6. **Alvesson, M. (1998).** "Gender relations and identity at work: A case study of masculinities and femininities in an advertising agency." _Human Relations_. This study examines gender dynamics within the workplace, illuminating forms of masculinity and femininity in a professional setting .

7. **Chafetz, J.S., & Fox, M.F. (2006).** "Gender, hierarchy, and science." In _Handbook of the Sociology of Gender_ (Springer). This chapter explores how gendered relations within the realm of science are hierarchical and often measured against masculine norms .

8. **Schrock, D., & Schwalbe, M. (2009).** "Men, masculinity, and manhood acts." _Annual Review of Sociology_. The authors discuss the construction of masculinity through "manhood acts" and the societal implications of such behaviors .


9. **Chafetz, J.S., & Epstein, C.F. (2006).** "Similarity and Difference: The Sociology of Gender Distinctions." In _Handbook of the Sociology of Gender_ (Springer). This work examines the boundaries that define male and female identities, challenging traditional assumptions about gender roles .

These references collectively offer a comprehensive exploration of gender theory's evolution, particularly in the context of masculinity studies, since Chafetz's initial work in 1978.


### In-Text Citations:

- Chafetz (2006) discusses the variety of gender theories in sociology, including the masculine pattern among married women in the workforce .

- Pitt and Fox (2012) introduce the concept of performative masculinity, expanding on Chafetz's theories .

- According to Chafetz (2001), feminist sociological theory has significantly evolved over three decades, impacting our understanding of masculinity .


### List of References:

1. Chafetz, J.S. (2006). The varieties of gender theory in sociology. In _Handbook of the Sociology of Gender_. Springer.

2. Pitt, S.L., & Fox, C.A. (2012). Performative masculinity: A new theory on masculinity. In _Masculinity/Femininity: Re-framing a Fragmented Debate_. Brill.

3. Chafetz, J.S. (2001). Theoretical understandings of gender: A third of a century of feminist thought in sociology. In _Handbook of Sociological Theory_. Springer.

4. Harrison, J.B. (1978). Men's roles and men's lives. _Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society_.

5. Chafetz, J.S. (1980). Theory development, nominal categories, and sex roles. _Free Inquiry in Creative Sociology_.

6. Alvesson, M. (1998). Gender relations and identity at work: A case study of masculinities and femininities in an advertising agency. _Human Relations_.

7. Chafetz, J.S., & Fox, M.F. (2006). Gender, hierarchy, and science. In _Handbook of the Sociology of Gender_. Springer.

8. Schrock, D., & Schwalbe, M. (2009). Men, masculinity, and manhood acts. _Annual Review of Sociology_.

9. Chafetz, J.S., & Epstein, C.F. (2006). Similarity and Difference: The Sociology of Gender Distinctions. In _Handbook of the Sociology of Gender_. Springer.


---


Use "LS" : List 9 Critical reading methods


***Beyond Scholar GPT?*** 

Try Browser Pro for searching across wide-ranging areas: [https://chat.openai.com/g/g-BlafpMvzd](https://bit.ly/3HL1k5g)

Kelas Daring Linguistik MLI - Linguistik Sistemik Fungsional

 Kelas Daring Linguistik MLI - Linguistik Sistemik Fungsional --

SFL appraisal-register-genre dan Ideology by Prof Dr Tri Wiranto, M.A

https://youtu.be/fbvyRbxvXDQ?si=VsfGZ_zUkjg_pwiv



Kelas Daring Linguistik MLI - Linguistik Sistemik Fungsional by Prof Riyadi Santosa:

https://www.youtube.com/live/ZcukjIzeIPA?si=Gl1nSzaddd8DwjjS